
Sunday, December 30, 2007
Camille Claudel (1989) ~ *****

Saturday, December 29, 2007
La Vita e Bella ~ Life is Beautiful (1997) *****
Synposis from Netflix:
In this poignant tragicomedy, a clever Jewish-Italian waiter named Guido (Roberto Benigni, who won an Oscar for his role) is sent to a Nazi concentration camp during World War II, along with his wife (Nicoletta Braschi) and their young son (Giorgio Cantarini). Refusing to give up hope, Guido tries to protect his son's innocence by pretending that their imprisonment is an elaborate game, with the grand prize being a tank. Benigni also directed.
Length:
117 minutes
Director:
Roberto Benigni
Cast:
Roberto Benigni
Nicoletta Braschi
Giustino Durano
Sergio Bini Bustric
I am not a big fan of war movies. Nor do I like movies about genocide. Movies where the Jewish are in concentration camps horrify me. It isn't that I deny that these things happen. It is the fact that I do not want to see how humans could be so terrible. And to see the devastation of what happened to an entire ethnicity is more than I can bear to watch. I really should know better. Learning about Chinese history and about Chinese tortures should have already educated me that humans can do evil like no other.
I was set to hate this movie. Why? Because I don't like to be reminded how bad people are and how humans can let terrible things happen without interfering. The start of the movie was totally unlike what I thought it would be. It really was a romantic type of comedy. "Bongiorno Principessa" was my favourite line in the movie. Roberto was a funny, light hearted, full of life and love. He was a goof ball that tried so hard to win a woman. For me it is true, a man who can make a woman laugh whole heartedly is a man to keep.
In the movie, it was obvious to me that Roberto was marrying up. And yet the couple made it work. They created a happy home filled with merriment and laughter. The only thorn in the side was the snobby mother in law. I am not sure if the MIL didn't understand her daughter or if she was just plain stupid. For the MIL to really believe that she could separate two obviously very in love man and woman was beyond ludicrous for me.
While the movie was really quite a comedy in the beginning, it took a turn for the worst and this was when I understood the tragedy. My heart weeps as I remember the conditions in the concentration camp. Roberto is an amazing actor. He demonstrates not only the love of man to woman, but of a father to a child. What he goes through to keep his child sheltered from the horrors of wartime is an unbeatable feat. The fear he keeps hidden from his young son leaves me speechless. The way he constantly works to generate hope in his son and for his wife moves me. It speaks of true love and dedication. Roberto exemplifies the phrase "I would die for you."
So when the end comes, it is with shock and despair. I could not believe the ending because all through the movie, I saw how Roberto overcomes adversity. In the end, when he dies, I could not stop the tears from seeping down my face, tear drop after tear drop falling into my lap. I am sure that my eyes were wide with disbelief. My ears were ringing with a silent roar. I left the theater in silence, the pain of the ending was too much for me to say a word.
Como Agua Para Chocolate ~ Like Water for Chocolate (1992) *****
The synposis from Netflix:
A feast for the senses, this magical romance from director Alfonso Arau was nominated for an Independent Spirit Award and a Golden Globe. The passionate Tita (Lumi Cavazos) is in love with Pedro (Marco Leonardi), but her controlling mother (Regina Torne) forbids her from marrying him. When Pedro instead marries her sister, Tita throws herself into her cooking -- and discovers she can transfer her emotions through the food she prepares.
Length:
105 minutes
Director:
Alfonso Arau
Cast:
Marco Leonardi
Como Agua Para Chocolate takes one into a world of old traditions. I am not familiar with Spanish traditions, so it came to me as a surprise when I learned in this movie that it is the youngest daughter who must take care of the aging parents. I do not know if this is really true or just a fabrication of the writer.
It is unfortunate that the youngest daughter is the prettiest and falls in love. In this star-crossed lover movie, one watches as duty and traditions over ride the desires of an individual. Whether I wanted to or not, I was dragged through the emotions of anger, rage, despair, and relief.
Rage - I raged against the evil mother. I could not understand how a mother could treat her three daughters so differently. I was angry that the one who could love her most and treat her best was most despised and tortured. How evil could a mother be? This one was pretty bad in my books because she knew her youngest fell in love with a man who loved her back. Instead of giving her blessings, she forcefully destroys the two and keeps them apart.
The mother forces the man to marry the middle sister. The middle sister is dull, unattractive and pretty much a useless person. She is also petty and jealous of her sisters so she goes forth and marries the man. What I never understood is how the man could have settled? I honestly don't believe he was worthy if he could submit so easily. To be married to the sister of the woman he desperately loves? To have to bed that ugly woman and have children with her? To have to daily see the woman he loves and never be with her? What kind of a wuss was he?
Throughout the movie, the youngest daughter is constantly humiliated and degraded. She is literately treated like a slave. I am not sure exactly how she survives. Entwined with the movie is the theme of food. The only outlet the young woman has is cooking. She is a kind heart woman who cooks food with much emotion.
The relief I felt was when the oldest daughter escapes the crazy household abet a very naughty way. She rides into the sunset with her lover, naked on horseback. I can't help but feel a bit of relief that someone has escaped. At the end, the middle daughter has died. The evil mother has died. Finally the two lovers after a life time may finally be together.
The ending was rather anti climatic and when it was over, I was stunned. The movie was building and building and at the end, it was as if we stopped only by driving at 100 mph to full stop at a brick wall. It hurt. I hated the ending.